Solution:
In \app\design\frontend\my_theme\default\template\wishlist\view.phtml
Add
url += '&form_key=' + jQuery('#wishlist-view-form input[name="form_key"]').val();
before setLocation(url);
In \app\design\frontend\my_theme\default\template\wishlist\view.phtml
Add
url += '&form_key=' + jQuery('#wishlist-view-form input[name="form_key"]').val();
before setLocation(url);